49 U.S.C. § 1154 doesn't distinguish between cockpit voice recorder audio and flight data recorder numbers. Both fall under the same statutory category, "cockpit or surface vehicle recorder," and both require the identical procedure to reach a civil litigant: a court must conduct an in camera review before allowing discovery of a recorder transcript. There is no tier where the numbers are public and the voices are locked away. That distinction, appealing as it is for a tidy thesis, doesn't survive contact with the statute's actual text.

What the statute does say, cleanly and absolutely, is this: no part of an NTSB accident report may be admitted into evidence in a civil damages action, full stop. Not "subject to review." Not "unless a judge disagrees." Barred. This is the provision doing the real legal work, and it creates a strange asymmetry nobody designed on purpose: the NTSB's own trained conclusions about what caused a crash, the single most informed analysis that will ever exist of the event, are legally inadmissible, while the raw underlying data the NTSB used to reach those conclusions can, after the in camera gate, end up in front of a jury with no expert synthesis attached to it.

That gap is where the real fight happens, and it isn't fought over access. It's fought over sequencing. The NTSB's "party system" grants certain organizations (the airline, the manufacturer, sometimes the union) direct access to raw data during the investigation, on the condition they not use it independently of the investigation's purpose. Whoever is inside that tent gets to build the first coherent story from numbers that, alone, tell no story at all. That first story anchors every juror, every reporter, and often the judge, long before an outside expert gets the same data through the in camera gate months or years later. This is a convexity problem dressed as a transparency rule: being first to interpret is worth more than being right eventually, because nobody un-anchors from a narrative just because a second, better one arrives late.

The fix isn't "more disclosure." Disclosure already happens, eventually, to everyone with standing to ask. The fix is pricing the sequencing advantage honestly instead of pretending equal eventual access means equal practical access, a distinction every litigator inside the party system understands and nobody writing about "public" black box data usually does.